Rarity Bay A Tellico Lake Community

Rarity Bay is a stunning 960-acre peninsula situated on Tellico Lake. With around 1600 home sites, this golf lakefront community boasts a French Country architectural style and strict guidelines to safeguard residents’ investments. From single-family homes to patio homes and condos along the golf course, Rarity Bay offers a range of housing options. Access to the community is gated, ensuring security through a monitored gatehouse. With more than ten miles of shoreline on Tellico Lake, Rarity Bay is among the three gated lakefront neighborhoods in the area, alongside Windriver and Thunder Pointe.

Discover a wealth of amenities at Rarity Bay, including access to the French Country Clubhouse, Equestrian Center, Championship golf course, community docking, and riding trails. The Country Club setting features tennis, a swimming pool, fitness facilities, and the Bristo/Bar for entertaining and dining. The 125-acre Equestrian Center includes a lighted arena, professionally maintained stables, and extensive hiking and riding trails. The adjoining 150-acre golf course was designed by D.J. DeVictor and Peter Langham, offering breathtaking views of Tellico Lake, Cherokee National Forest, and The Great Smoky Mountain National Park.

Living in Rarity Bay comes with its perks, especially when it comes to taxes. Tennessee residents can rejoice in the fact that they are exempt from paying income tax, even on their retirement income. Kiplinger Media recently highlighted Tennessee as one of the top states for retirement, thanks to its tax-friendly environment, affordable cost of living, and financially stable state.

Real Estate Listings in Rarity Bay:

See all Rarity Bay.
(all data current as of 5/20/2026)

Listing information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Read full disclaimer.